Cashflow Diary Direct

Cashflow Diary Direct

Share this post

Cashflow Diary Direct
Cashflow Diary Direct
Beyoncé made me an extra $2,000 on Airbnb - without even staying there
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More

Beyoncé made me an extra $2,000 on Airbnb - without even staying there

Stop copying competitor prices! The hidden reason your Airbnb is losing money

J. Massey's avatar
J. Massey
May 16, 2025
∙ Paid
3

Share this post

Cashflow Diary Direct
Cashflow Diary Direct
Beyoncé made me an extra $2,000 on Airbnb - without even staying there
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
2
Share

When you want to build a profitable short-term rental business without constantly guessing at your pricing strategy, you need a system that works while you sleep.

Most hosts waste hours matching competitor prices or using Airbnb's Smart Pricing—only to discover they've been leaving thousands on the table or worse, booking guests below their break-even point.

I learned this the hard way. Over a decade ago, I stepped into the STR world and immediately felt like I was in quicksand. I'd spend hours researching comparable properties, only to second-guess my rates when bookings slowed.

Here's what I learned: Airbnb pricing isn't just about matching competitors. It's about creating a system that adapts to market changes while you sleep.

The truth? Most new hosts face this exact struggle. They waste time trying to balance "competitive" rates with actual profit, all while missing the fundamental point: pricing is the hardest part of this business because it's about delivering clear value to specific target customers. Without knowing exactly who you're serving, the Airbnb algorithm isn't the only thing judging your pricing decisions—the market is, too.

Let me share the strategies that helped me increase my monthly revenue by 32% without working additional hours.

IN THIS ISSUE:

  • The Break-Even Rule That Changed Everything: How to calculate your absolute minimum rate (and why charging more is crucial)

  • Strategic Seasonal Pricing: The tiered approach that added $6,000 to my annual revenue

  • The "Ripple Effect" Opportunity: How events 100 miles away can double your rates overnight

  • Beyond the Nightly Rate: The McDonald's pricing secret that transformed my profit margins

  • Turn Cleaning Into a Profit Center: How I added $15-20 profit per booking with a simple tweak

These approaches work whether you have one apartment or ten cabins. They apply in big cities and small towns. And they don't require complex spreadsheets or an MBA to implement.

Let's dive in.

Share

Airbnb Hosts & Short-Term Rental Operators w/ 0 - 20 units:

We'll Guarantee You an ADDITIONAL $10,000 Per Month For 5 Months Consecutively, Through Our Done-FOR-You Reservation Growth Model…

OR You DON’T Pay AND I’ll Send You $1994 For Wasting Your Time…

Click the button below, enter in your info and we'll text you a one-pager on how this works.

Click Here For More Info

When Airbnb Pricing Feels Like Guesswork: The Hidden System Most Hosts Miss

I'd spend hours researching comparable properties, only to second-guess my rates when bookings slowed. Sound familiar?

When I first listed my property, I made the classic mistake of setting one flat rate year-round. My calendar stayed full during the off-season (great!), but I missed thousands in potential earnings during peak periods (not so great).

This pattern repeats for nearly every new host—and it stems from a fundamental misunderstanding of what successful STR pricing actually is.

"Occupancy is vanity, profit is sanity."

Most hosts obsess over filling every night when they should be focusing on maximizing profit per booking. An 80% occupied property with strategic pricing and add-on services can be significantly more profitable than a 95% occupied property competing solely on price.

Let me share the exact system that transformed my approach from reactive guesswork to strategic advantage.

User's avatar
Join J. Massey’s subscriber chat
Available in the Substack app and on web

Strategy 1: Know Your Minimum Viable Rate (Then Focus on Value)

Before making any pricing decisions, you need clarity on your absolute baseline—not to charge this rate, but to know where your hard floor stands.

When I first started hosting, I made the mistake of focusing solely on what others charged. But smart pricing starts with understanding your own numbers. Your pricing strategy must begin with financial clarity and then quickly move to value-based positioning.

Start by calculating your break-even point—the absolute minimum you need to charge to cover all expenses. This includes mortgage/rent, utilities, cleaning fees, supplies, Airbnb service fees, taxes, and a maintenance reserve.

For a two-bedroom condo, this breakdown was eye-opening:

  1. Monthly mortgage and HOA fees: $1,800

  2. Average utilities: $240

  3. Cleaning costs (assuming 10 turnovers/month): $650

  4. Supplies/replacements: $120

  5. Airbnb fees (average): $290

  6. Taxes and insurance: $350

  7. Maintenance reserve: $100

  8. Total monthly expenses: $3,550

Dividing by 30 days, I needed to average $118 per night just to break even. But this calculation revealed something critical: during weekdays in my market, many comparable listings charged only $99-109.

The solution wasn't lowering my price to match competitors (which would guarantee a loss). Instead, I needed to focus on what specific value I could offer to guests willing to pay rates that would actually be profitable.

Your Action Step: Use our break-even calculator to determine your absolute minimum rate, then shift focus to the specific value you can offer that justifies rates well above this floor.

Leave a comment

Strategy 2: Master Seasonal Pricing Adjustments

The biggest pricing mistake I see new hosts make is setting the same rate year-round. This approach guarantees you'll either leave money on the table during high season or sit vacant during low season.

In one of my markets (suburban Texas), summer weekends can command 40% higher rates than winter weekdays. But I discovered this pattern too late, after locking in several peak-season bookings at off-season rates.

Creating a seasonal pricing calendar isn't complex, but it requires local market knowledge. My approach focuses on identifying your market's specific patterns:

First, map out your local demand drivers to effectively price your Airbnb. In my area, these include:

  • Summer vacation season (June-August)

  • Holiday periods (Thanksgiving, Christmas, New Year's)

  • Major sporting events

  • University calendar events (graduation, move-in weekend)

  • Local festivals and conventions

From this analysis, I created five distinct seasonal pricing tiers:

  • Peak season (30-40% above baseline)

  • High season (15-25% above baseline)

  • Shoulder season (baseline rates)

  • Low season (10-15% below baseline)

  • Off-season (20-30% below baseline)

This tiered approach increased my annual revenue by over $6,000 compared to flat-rate pricing, even with the same overall occupancy.

The real power comes from adjusting these seasonal rates based on the day of the week. In my market, Friday and Saturday command a 25-35% premium over weekdays. By implementing both seasonal and day-of-week adjustments, I effectively stopped subsidizing weekday guests with lost weekend revenue.

Your Action Step: Create a simple calendar mapping your market's high and low seasons, then set clear price tiers for each. This foundation will support all your other pricing strategies.


What if you could literally watch me implement these pricing strategies on my own properties?

That's exactly what happens inside the Cashflow Diary Cartel.

While our newsletter provides valuable insights, Cartel members get exclusive access to:

  • Implementation Tutorials: Watch me set up these systems in real-time

  • Monthly Strategy Calls: Get your specific pricing questions answered

  • Private Community Access: Connect with successful operators in your market

  • Advanced Notification System: Be first to know about market shifts and opportunities

    Get 87% off forever

Plus: Our STR Pricing Implementation Vault with all calculators, templates, and scripts—a $1,997 value included with your membership.

The difference between good advice and real implementation is where wealth is built.

JOIN THE CARTEL TODAY →

Get 87% off forever

Offer valid for the next 100, 99, 98, ... 90, 89, … 81 or May 30th, 2025 whichever comes first.

Strategy 3: Understand the Ripple Effects of External Events

One of the most eye-opening realizations in my STR journey was how seemingly unrelated events can dramatically impact demand and pricing in unexpected ways.

Pricing in this business is ever-changing because the world is interconnected in ways most hosts never consider. Let me share a counterintuitive example that taught me this lesson:

  1. A hurricane in Texas affected my bookings in California.

  2. You might wonder what Texas weather has to do with California occupancy.

  3. The answer? American Airlines—and therefore everything.

American has major hubs in Texas that connect thousands of travelers to California daily. When those hubs get disrupted, people get stuck, new arrivals can't come in, and suddenly, your California property faces unexpected vacancies even though it's sunny and perfect outside your door.

This kind of butterfly effect happens constantly in the STR world, and most hosts completely miss it. When I started monitoring these broader connections, I developed a new approach to pricing that includes:


Turn These Strategies Into Reality With Our Implementation Guides

Now that you understand the pricing framework that can transform your STR business, you need the tools to implement it systematically.

Get 87% off forever

For Cashflow Diary Cartel members, we've just released our complete STR Pricing Implementation System, including:

  • Break-Even Calculator with auto-formulas

  • Seasonal Pricing Calendar Template

  • Event Monitoring System

  • Value-Add Package Creation Guide

  • Guest Retention Email Sequence

  • Cleaning Profit Center Calculator

  • And much more...

Ready to stop leaving money on the table?

JOIN THE CASHFLOW DIARY CARTEL TODAY →

Get 87% off forever

Our members are reporting revenue increases of 20-40% within 60 days of implementing these systems. Don't miss out on the thousands in additional revenue these strategies can generate for your STR business.

Keep reading with a 7-day free trial

Subscribe to Cashflow Diary Direct to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 West Egg Enterprises, Inc.
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share

Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More